Planning a trip to Italy can feel overwhelming. There are so many cities, regions, and opinions about what you should see. After spending 12 days exploring the country, this is the itinerary I’d recommend to almost anyone visiting Italy for the first time.
Italy had been at the top of my travel list for years, and after finally making the trip, I can confidently say it exceeded every expectation. Rather than trying to see every famous destination, I built an itinerary that balanced history, incredible food, unforgettable experiences, and enough flexibility to simply enjoy being there. Looking back, I wouldn’t change much. Each city offered something completely different, and together they created a trip that never felt rushed.
If you’re planning your first visit to Italy, here’s the route I took, why I chose each destination, and a few lessons I learned along the way.
Why I Chose This Route
Before I booked a single flight or hotel, I wanted an itinerary that gave me a little bit of everything Italy is known for without feeling like I was constantly packing, rushing, or checking attractions off a list.
Here’s who I think this itinerary is perfect for:
Best for: First-time visitors to Italy.
Trip style: A balanced mix of history, incredible food, wine, scenic train rides, and cities you can experience almost entirely on foot.
Pace: Relaxed enough to enjoy each destination without feeling like you’re racing from one attraction to the next.
Would I change anything? Only one thing—I would stay closer to Bologna’s city center. It would have made getting around much easier.
Trip at a Glance
Duration: 12 Days
Route: Rome → Florence & Tuscany → Bologna → Venice → Rome
Transportation: Italy’s high-speed trains connected every city, making travel simple, comfortable, and one of the most enjoyable parts of the trip. One of my biggest surprises was how much I looked forward to the train rides themselves—they became part of the experience rather than just transportation.
Worth the Splurge: If there’s one expense I’d gladly pay for again, it’s upgrading our seats on the long-haul flight to and from Italy. Having the extra space to stretch out, sleep, and arrive feeling rested made a noticeable difference once we landed. For a trip like this, where you’re ready to start exploring the moment you arrive, it was worth every penny.
Rome
If it’s your first time in Italy, I don’t think there’s a better place to begin than Rome. The city immediately immerses you in history while still feeling vibrant and modern.
I spent my first few days exploring the Colosseum, Roman Forum, Palatine Hill, and, of course, the Trevi Fountain. Beyond the landmarks, though, what I enjoyed most was simply walking. We covered miles every day, yet thanks to Apple Maps, we somehow never felt lost. Wandering through different neighborhoods led us to cafés, wine bars, and restaurants we never would have found if we’d planned every meal in advance—and every single one was exceptional.
Rome also had my favorite atmosphere after dark. Restaurants spilled onto the sidewalks, people lingered over dinner and drinks late into the evening, and the city felt just as alive at 10 p.m. as it did earlier in the day. One of the unexpected surprises was discovering Doppelgänger, an Italian clothing brand I’d never heard of before. It quickly became one of my favorite shopping finds from the entire trip.
Rome reminded me that history isn’t confined to museums—it’s woven into everyday life.
Florence & Tuscany
Florence slowed everything down in the best possible way.
The city is incredibly walkable, making it easy to spend hours exploring the streets, browsing shops, stopping for gelato, or enjoying another glass of wine. I visited the Duomo, wandered through the historic center, and appreciated the slower pace compared to Rome.
The highlight of my time here was easily the pizza and gelato making class at a farm in the Tuscan countryside. It wasn’t just a cooking class—it became one of the most memorable experiences of the entire trip. I also took a day trip to Cinque Terre before finishing the day in Pisa to see the Leaning Tower, making for one of the most scenic days of the vacation.
Every meal felt intentional. Whether it was fresh pasta, pizza, wine, or gelato, Florence consistently delivered the best overall dining experience of the trip. By the time I left, I found myself wishing I had just one more day.
If I had to spend one extra day anywhere on this itinerary, it would probably be Florence.
Bologna
I only spent one night in Bologna, but I’d include it on this itinerary every time.
Because I visited on a Sunday, the city had a noticeably slower, more relaxed feel than Rome or Florence, which made for a nice change of pace. If I could do one thing differently, I’d stay closer to the city center. My hotel was about 15 minutes away, and finding taxis wasn’t always easy, making transportation more difficult than it needed to be.
The reason to visit Bologna, though, is the food. Dinner at Osteria dell’Orsa turned out to be the single best meal of my entire trip. Afterward, we grabbed gelato and took a long evening walk beneath the city’s famous porticos—a simple ending to one of my favorite nights in Italy.
One dinner alone made Bologna worth adding to the itinerary.
Venice
Venice feels like nowhere else in the world.
I stayed just steps from the Rialto Bridge, which meant I could walk almost everywhere and was right in the middle of the city’s energy. Every evening ended the same way—in the best possible sense—with dinner along the canals, a glass of wine, and another stop for gelato.
I took a gondola ride through the canals, explored St. Mark’s Square, and spent hours wandering across bridges and through narrow alleyways without worrying about where I was headed. At times it felt like I was walking through a movie set rather than a real city.
Venice isn’t a city to rush through. It’s one to experience slowly, and that’s exactly what made it so memorable.
Venice isn’t a city you conquer—it’s one you experience.
Why This Itinerary Worked
Looking back, I think what made this trip so memorable wasn’t just the destinations—it was the balance.
Rome gave me history and energy. Florence offered incredible food and unforgettable experiences. Bologna introduced me to one of the best meals I’ve ever had. Venice slowed everything down and reminded me that sometimes the best travel memories come from simply wandering.
The high-speed trains made moving between cities effortless, and ending the trip with one night near Rome’s airport made for a completely stress-free departure the next morning. Every stop felt different, which kept the experience fresh from beginning to end.
Tips for Planning Your Italy Trip
Before You Go
• Use Italy’s high-speed rail system. It was one of the easiest and most enjoyable parts of the trip.
• Stay within walking distance of each city’s historic center whenever possible. You’ll spend far less time worrying about transportation and more time exploring.
• If you’re flying home from Rome, consider spending your final night near the airport. It made departure day completely stress-free.
• Download offline maps before you arrive. Apple Maps worked flawlessly throughout my trip, but having offline maps is a great backup if your signal drops.
• Don’t over-plan every meal. Some of my favorite restaurants were places I simply stumbled upon while walking.
• Build in at least one memorable experience, whether it’s a cooking class, a wine tour, or another local activity. Those ended up being the memories I still talk about the most.
While You’re There
• If you’re visiting during the summer, prepare for the heat. Carry a reusable water bottle because public drinking fountains are everywhere, especially in Rome, and the water is cold, clean, and free.
• Bring a small hand towel from your hotel each day. Wet it with water from the public fountains—it became one of the easiest ways to cool off while walking around the cities.
• Pack bug spray if you’re visiting during the warmer months, especially if you’re spending time outdoors in the evenings or in the countryside.
• Don’t be afraid to walk. Apple Maps was incredibly reliable throughout the trip, and walking between attractions often became just as memorable as the destinations themselves. Some of my favorite cafés, restaurants, and even a new favorite clothing brand were discoveries I never would have made otherwise.
• Bring comfortable walking shoes. You’ll likely walk 15,000 to 25,000 steps a day without even realizing it.
• Carry a Visa or Mastercard. I found that many restaurants and smaller businesses didn’t accept American Express.
• Don’t stress about tipping. In most restaurants and businesses, it’s optional rather than expected. That said, whenever I did leave a tip, it was genuinely appreciated.
• Embrace the Italian dining experience. Many restaurants offer a traditional four-course meal, and I’d encourage you to enjoy it at least once. The ingredients are incredibly fresh, the portions are well paced, and after walking all day, you’ve probably earned every bite.
• Eat the gelato. Every chance you get.
• Leave time to wander. Some of my favorite memories came when I wasn’t following the itinerary at all.
Final Thoughts
Looking back, I don’t think what made this trip special was any one landmark.
It was the balance. The history of Rome. The pace of Florence. The food of Bologna. The atmosphere of Venice.
Each city brought something completely different, and together they created an itinerary I’d recommend to almost anyone planning their first trip to Italy.
Italy has a way of making you appreciate the big moments—the Colosseum, the Duomo, the canals—but it’s often the smaller ones you’ll remember most: an incredible meal you didn’t plan, an evening walk with gelato in hand, discovering a new favorite shop, or a quiet glass of wine after miles of exploring.
If someone asked me tomorrow how to spend their first trip to Italy, I’d hand them this itinerary and tell them to leave room for the unexpected. Those unplanned moments often become the memories you’ll treasure the longest.
gathandborden.com 